Back to Top

Research Roundup 1

Reflections on the implications of 5 psychological studies

Long before Twitter necessitated brevity, it was in ancient Greece that Socrates uttered the concise words, “First know yourself.”1

Sages have continually uttered it over the millennia, but wherever this phrase originated, I think we need to heed its message as a matter of urgency.

Why do these words matter?

Because right now there is no excuse for the human race not to know itself. We are simply swimming in psychological research. The information is there. What remains to be seen is how we are going to apply that information. And here’s a thought:

Perhaps we have to know ourselves if we are to survive.

Understanding the human condition may not be a navel-gazing luxury but a staring-down-the-barrel-of-a-gun necessity. There are no guarantees the human race will survive.

The dinosaurs lived for 135 million years and left the Earth more or less as they found it. Human civilization, on the other hand, has been around for about 12,000 years – and it hasn’t always seemed that civilized. Make no mistake, we can destroy ourselves. We can destroy ourselves through anger, short-sightedness, or out-of-control groupthink.

Understanding who we are and what we need may now be vital. We all need to know what we need to be emotionally healthy and satisfied. We need to understand how people come to believe what they do and why emotional problems develop. And we can also understand that whole cultures suffer emotional problems and blind spots just as individuals do.

But there’s something else.

Not waving but drowning

Yes, we have greater access to psychological knowledge than ever before. But we are also bombarded with it. “This study says that; that study says this!” We nod with interest, then we move on. It doesn’t change us or give us wisdom.

Being inundated with information without having formed bigger organizing ideas in order to contextualize that information may be worse than useless. As a species we don’t want to die in the midst of plenty. We don’t want to drown in a quagmire of information without absorbing what it truly means for us; how it fits in with wider understanding.

Now I understand that not all research is repeatable or even applicable, but much of it may simply be suggestive of wider psychological truths – and that’s what this series is about. I will summarize pieces of research and provide my own imperfect take on that research: what it might signify in a wider sense.

So with that as a rather grand opener, I want to highlight five recent pieces of  research and attempt to lend some context to them. There’s no overarching theme here – the pieces are pretty random. But hopefully I will cover quite a spectrum of interest.

Okay, let’s get started! This month we have:

  1. Rock climbing and depression
  2. Severe mental illness and cardiovascular disease
  3. Bullying’s lasting impact
  4. Visual creatives’ poor sleep
  5. Positive emotions in dying

Research piece one: Rock climbing is a great treatment for depression

You may laugh, but maybe it’s no more crazy than pharmaceutical or electric shock treatment. In one study, a researcher had depressed participants start bouldering, a form of rock climbing, and found a correlation between the activity and feelings of improved wellbeing.

If this is a genuine effect, why might that be?

I would suggest the following.

  • Bouldering is social and therefore meets the need for connection to other people: a need that is lacking in many unhappy people.2
  • Bouldering works the body, and exercise has been found to be as effective as antidepressants in lifting depressive symptoms.3
  • Learning and improving a skill can help with self-esteem, a vital part of a healthy psychology.
  • There may be a metaphorical impact of ‘climbing up’ and ‘looking up’, which affects the mind and body in positive ways. We call this embodied cognition.4 Just as the way we feel affects the way we use our bodies, the way we use our bodies affects the way we feel.
  • Depression inhibits the function of the prefrontal lobe.5 This part of the neo-cortex of the brain is involved with the generation of positive feelings and emotional regulation, but also with planning and strategic thinking, spotting problems and overcoming them. Bouldering may force us to think strategically and therefore mobilize this antidepressant brain structure. Just a thought!
  • Bouldering has a beginning, a middle, and an end. We know that depressed people ruminate6 a lot but often feel paralyzed when it comes to actually solving their problems. When people boulder they are completing something, switching off an expectation. Any activity that has a beginning, middle, and end is likely to have antidepressant effects.
  • Rumination, living inside your own head and mulling, seems to drive depression.7 When bouldering we don’t have time to ruminate because we are deeply focused on the activity.

The researchers seem very enthusiastic about the antidepressant effects of bouldering, but I would suggest that any activity that produces the effects I’ve suggested might have similar benefits. Still, it’s great to see researchers considering an intervention that isn’t drug based.

Research piece two: Severe mental illness linked to much higher risk for cardiovascular disease

When treating our clients I think it’s important to consider how emotional difficulties can impact physical health (and vice versa), especially in the long term. This interesting piece of research considers just that.

A recent article in Science Daily reports the following:8

An international study of more than 3.2 million people with severe mental illness reveals a substantially increased risk for developing cardiovascular disease compared to the general population.

Led by King’s College London, the research shows that people with severe mental illness (SMI), including schizophrenia, bipolar disorder and major depression, have a 53 per cent higher risk for having cardiovascular disease than healthy controls, with a 78 per cent higher risk of developing cardiovascular disease over the longer term. Their risk of dying from the disease was also 85 per cent higher than people of a similar age in the general population.

New Ways of Seeing Ebook

Get my book FREE when you subscribe to my therapy techniques newsletter

Download my book on reframing, "New Ways of Seeing", when you subscribe for free email updates

Click to subscribe free now

Wow! That’s pretty scary. As the researchers posit, some of this may be attributable to prescribed medications and their side effects, including weight gain and appetite changes.

My two-penneth worth?

Well, undoubtedly weight gain can be dramatic when taking antidepressants and psychotropic drugs such as antipsychotics, and genetics obviously plays a key role, but I think there’s another factor that tracks right alongside cardiovascular disease: stress.

  • We know that depressed people are stressed people,9 and people who have suffered psychotic ‘breakdowns’ often report a prolonged period of stress before the breakdown.
  • Low social status correlates with increased incidence of heart disease,10 and those living with mental illness often also suffer low social status.
  • Mentally ill people often report fractured relationships and a sense of disconnection from people around them. Loneliness itself is another risk factor for cardiovascular disease.11
  • ‘There may be other physical factors at play in both heart disease and mental instability that we don’t yet recognize, such as histamine and methylation problems.12
  • Stress can cause mental illness in some people, but the reverse also applies. Mental illness produces more stress as it becomes harder to meet basic material and emotional needs.

So rather than simply looking at people as a container for chemicals, we need to see them in their psychological and social aspects as well.

Stress is a central component of much mental illness, and long-term stress has consequences. We become stressed when we don’t meet our physical and emotional needs adequately and healthily.

Research piece three: Bullying’s lasting impact

Speaking of stress and not meeting emotional needs, a new study from the University of Delaware has found that children who are bullied in fifth grade are more likely to suffer from depression in seventh grade, and to use alcohol, marijuana or tobacco in tenth grade.13

This is a sad but not surprising report. Actually, I’ve seen another report suggesting that the pernicious effects of bullying can last deep into adulthood, severely damaging physical and mental health.14

Even more heartbreakingly, the new report finds that children who are already suffering from chronic illness are more likely to be bullied.

Other risk factors for being bullied include being male and being a “sexual minority youth”. No correlation was found between incidence of bullying and age, obesity, ethnicity, household educational achievement, or family income.

My take on this?

Well I think it’s pretty clear. We all have basic primal emotional needs. Bullying works by blocking the completion of these needs in others. We all have a need to feel:

  • A sense of control. Bullying may make us feel so powerless that we develop ‘learned helplessness’, where we overgeneralize the feeling of powerlessness to apply it even in situations in which we would have control if we did but know it and use it.
  • A sense of status and healthy self-esteem. We all need to feel we are ‘somebody’, to be recognized as being valuable or esteemed in some way. Bullying can make us feel valueless when we come to view ourselves the way the bullies seem to view us.
  • A sense of connection to other people, of being part of a community. Bullying may isolate us from others.
  • A sense of safety and security. Bullying can make us uncertain and afraid.

The report suggests that interventions take place in schools, but doesn’t really suggest what those interventions might be. How do we tackle bullying? For a start I think children need to understand what it is, how it happens, and how we can mitigate its effects, but there are no simple answers.

Research piece four: Visually creative people sleep longer, but less well

This study on creativity and sleep quality caught my eye. Researchers at The University of Haifa compared art students and social science students, and found that art students sleep more hours, but the quality of the sleep is often poor.

In a report on the university’s website, Neta Ram-Vlasov, one of the authors, explains, “[v]isually creative people reported disturbed sleep leading to difficulties in daytime functioning”.15 Small solace for problem sleepers, although most people I know would probably exchange decent sleep for a bucketful of visual creativity.

Ram-Vlasov goes on to say, “[i]n the case of verbally creative people, we found that they sleep more hours and go to sleep and get up later. In other words, the two types of creativity were associated with different sleep patterns. This strengthens the hypothesis that the processing and expression of visual creativity involves different psychobiological mechanisms to those found in verbal creativity.”

Creativity is often defined in the literature as consisting of four main aspects:

  • Fluency: the ability to produce a wide range of ideas
  • Flexibility: The ability to switch easily between different thought patterns in order to produce this wide range of ideas
  • Originality: The unique quality of the ideas relative to other ideas in the environment
  • Elaboration: the ability to develop each idea separately.

The authors don’t draw any concrete conclusions as to why the two kinds of creativity, verbal and visual, seem to be associated with different kinds of sleep quality. They do suggest that “[i]t is possible that a ‘surplus’ of visual creativity makes the individual more alert, and this could lead to sleep disturbances. On the other hand, it is possible that it is protracted sleep among verbally [creative] individuals that facilitates processes that support the creative process while they are awake.”

But here are my ideas:

  • The most visually creative you can be is to actually hallucinate. When we dream we are all incredibly visually creative, but when REM sleep is suppressed we may be more likely to hallucinate while actually awake, as the dreaming brain seeks expression.
  • If REM sleep is somewhat suppressed but not entirely, we might expect, rather than hallucination, a greater sense of visual creativity.
  • Verbal creativity has much to do with expressing the creative flow through the medium of language. Too much REM disturbance might cause creative ‘word salad‘. Indeed, sleep deprivation will often eventually lead to word salad even in (usually) non-psychotic individuals.

If REM sleep is somewhat suppressed, we might expect a greater sense of visual creativity

So I suspect the reasons behind the findings of this study may lie in the REM state. Hypnosis seems to be a controlled way of tapping into waking REM states, which may be why visual creativity often seems to be enhanced via hypnotic experience.

Research piece five: Emotions expressed by the dying are unexpectedly positive

This last piece jumped out at me because I had been in an email exchange with someone about their acute fear of and obsession with death. The person was young and healthy but couldn’t get used to the idea or thought of death. They got some solace from my article here. Coincidentally, a day after this exchange, a research piece came out in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.

Science Daily summarizes the article thus: “Fear of death is a fundamental part of the human experience – we dread the possibility of pain and suffering and we worry that we’ll face the end alone. Although thinking about dying can cause considerable angst, new research suggests that the actual emotional experiences of the dying are both more positive and less negative than people expect.”16

The research examined the writings of terminally ill people and those facing execution, and found that those facing death would often see wider perspectives than expected.

According to one of the authors, psychological scientist Kurt Gray of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, “[w]hen we imagine our emotions as we approach death, we think mostly of sadness and terror. But it turns out, dying is less sad and terrifying – and happier – than you think … the final blog posts of terminally ill patients and the last words of death row inmates are filled with love, social connection, and meaning.”

Even stranger perhaps, the researchers found that people’s use of positive words such as ‘hope’ and ‘love’ increased as death approached, but the use of negative words did not.

Science Daily concludes that “the findings suggest that our expectations may not match the reality of dying, which has important implications for how we treat people who are dying.”

My take?

Well, the authors of the report admit that they didn’t study people dying of old age or facing huge uncertainty as to whether they will die or not. But I still think it’s very suggestive. So what might it suggest?

  • Human beings are incredibly adaptive. Expecting and imagining to feel a certain way in a certain situation is no guarantee of actually feeling that way when we cross that bridge.
  • We should never assume we know what something will be like or what others ‘must’ be experiencing. Instead, we can say: “I’ll cross that bridge when I come to it” or “I’ll see what I’m like when I cross that bridge.”
  • Mysterious mechanisms seem to mobilize within our minds and bodies when we are faced with personal extinction, just as reality can feel dreamlike or go into slow-mo during an emergency. The you that operates when the ‘worst’ happens isn’t necessarily the same you that contemplates the worst happening.

The concept of a mysterious mechanism in the mind (like the dream reality so often experienced during emergencies) that prepares us for death is intriguing. There are many anecdotal reports of near-death consciousness, going down a tunnel or passage toward a bright light, feeling reconnected to loved ones and so forth which are also suggestive that dying is not the experience many expect.17

Or perhaps we become forced to see the bigger picture when the end of our time is close. There may be more inside of us all than we realize.

Anyway, I hope that you’ve enjoyed this random sample of recent psychological research and that I helped connect it up to bigger patterns of understanding – at least a little.

Please let me know your take on these different pieces of research in the comments below, and together as a community perhaps we can draw some of these disparate pieces of research together.

New Ways of Seeing Ebook

Get my book FREE when you subscribe to my therapy techniques newsletter

Download my book on reframing, "New Ways of Seeing", when you subscribe for free email updates

Click to subscribe free now

Mark Tyrrell

About Mark Tyrrell

Psychology is my passion. I've been a psychotherapist trainer since 1998, specializing in brief, solution focused approaches. I now teach practitioners all over the world via our online courses.

You can get my book FREE when you subscribe to my therapy techniques newsletter. Click here to subscribe free now.

Notes:

  1. Actually, these words have been attributed to all kinds of ancient sages and it seems likely they originated on the wall of the outer temple of the Karac complex of ancient Egypt: “Man first know thyself and you shall know the Gods.” It seems it was necessary to know or understand the self before spiritual progress could be made in the inner temple.
  2. http://journals.lww.com/nursingresearchonline/Abstract/1999/07000/The_Effects_of_Sense_of_Belonging,_Social_Support,.4.aspx
  3. http://www.ajpmonline.org/article/S0749-3797(13)00451-0/fulltext
  4. For examples of research on embodied cognition, see: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022103111001612; http://eprints.lancs.ac.uk/59565/ and http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0278262613000390
  5. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2907136/
  6. http://www.humangivens.com/joe-griffin/dreamcatcher.html
  7. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-24444431 and also http://www.clinical-depression.co.uk/dlp/understanding-depression/using-the-cycle-of-depression/
  8. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/05/170512195753.htm
  9. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0306453005000831
  10. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0021968169900022
  11. http://heart.bmj.com/content/early/2016/03/15/heartjnl-2015-308790
  12. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2689845
  13. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/05/170508144650.htm
  14. http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0956797613481608
  15. http://www.haifa.ac.il/index.php/en/2012-12-16-11-30-12/new-media/68-english/tehuda-eng/2298-creative-people-sleep-more-later-and-less-well
  16. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/06/170601124022.htm
  17. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1836313/

Search for more therapy techniques:

  • One thought about your prologue to the piece, where you discuss the state of being inundated in knowledge. If find the following quote compelling:

    “Reports that say that something hasn’t happened are always interesting to me, because as we know, there are known knowns; there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns — the ones we don’t know we don’t know. And if one looks throughout the history of our country and other free countries, it is the latter category that tend to be the difficult ones.”

    —Donald Rumsfeld, United States Secretary of Defense, b. 9 July 1932

    I understand that the name Rumsfeld may be a gauntlet flung to the ground depending on one’s political alignments, but that doesn’t prevent us from acknowledging the fundamental importance of this particular sentiment: what we don’t know what we don’t know is disquieting, I think.

    • Hi Milan and thanks for this and actually I think Rumsfeld was being quite profound although that speech as been pretty pilloried : )

Share83
Tweet
Share1
Email