Back to Top

3 Easy Questions In Diagnosing PTSD

Diagnosing PTSD
When you understand exactly what PTSD is doing to your clients' memories, it's so much easier to diagnose

She kept fainting and it was ruining her young life.

She’d had it all: PET, EEG, CT, fMRI scans, plus brain tests I’d never heard of. They’d found nothing.

Emily’s mother Jane brought her to me for hypnosis, but Emily, intelligent and articulate at 15, did most of the talking.

“I hate this! My friends go on about how they’d like to change their body shape, or something about their face, but the only thing I want to change is this, to stop fainting!”

Emily told me how she had fainted while out boating on a school trip to France and had to be rescued. School trips were now out for her. She told me how she’d fainted on the stairs at school, and fallen half way down the flight, obliviously unconscious. She rolled up her sleeve and showed me the lingering scar on her forearm. So now she was no longer allowed upstairs at school.

She explained how she couldn’t accept invitations for sleepovers, because she was worried about passing out at a friend’s house (although it had only ever happened at school).

I started to wonder… and I didn’t like what I was thinking.

Trauma Treatment

Discover How Thousands of Therapists Stop PTSD Symptoms in a Single Session

Click here to find out more

Is there a payoff?

Uncharitably (and briefly), I wondered whether Emily was getting some kind of subconscious pay off for her proneness to falling unconscious. Certainly she’d been marked out for special treatment, and had received an unusual amount of attention and compassion.

But this explanation just didn’t feel quite right to me.

Emily told me she’d had months of therapy with a cognitive behavioural therapist. But she’d found the analysis of all her thoughts had, if anything, made her feel more anxious, and she believed this had actually increased her fainting fits.

So then I started to think there might be some traumatic cause for this. And I used three questions to find out.

Three questions that help in diagnosing PTSD

Question 1: Did anything in particular happen around the time the symptom first occurred?

This seems so obvious and yet it surprising how often it gets missed. (I’m ashamed to admit that it was not till my second session with Emily that I got around to this question myself!)

I asked Emily how long she had lived with these life restricting fainting fits.

“About two years now.”

“And did anything happen to upset you around the time they started?”

Here Emily’s mum Jane interjected: “Well, actually, there were a couple of upsetting things back then, weren’t there Emily…?”

It turned out that Emily had been very close to their 70 year old neighbour, Pam. Seemingly much younger than her years, Pam was a vibrant and lively woman and like another grandmother to Emily, with whom she had a great relationship. It was a terrible shock for Emily to come home from school one day and hear from her dad that this lovely neighbour Pam had died very suddenly.

But there was more to come.

Only a few weeks later, Emily returned from school to yet another awful shock. The beloved family dog had been run down in the street and killed.

“Come to think of it,” said Jane, “it was just around that time that you started fainting at school, Emily…”

It's incredible how metaphorical the human mind can be. Click to Tweet

These two deaths had occurred when Emily was not at home. She was at school. Her brain had perhaps tagged ‘school’ as, if not the cause of, then at least associated with, the death of loved ones.

Of course she knew consciously that her beloved neighbour and her darling dog had died for reasons completely unconnected with herself and her actions or whereabouts. But her subconscious mind had made a link.

When traumatized we try to complete patterns through dreaming, talking, rituals or metaphorically acting out. Like ‘dying’ while at school by having fainting fits.

This was a neat explanation, but I pushed my theories aside and determined not to assume anything. So I explored further.

Question 2: Does it make you really upset to talk about it, even now?

This is such an important part of assessing whether a particular memory needs de-traumatizing.

“Emily, when you think about that time when your dad told you about Pam, does it still feel raw and painful, even now, two years later?”

Emily took a few seconds to recall the moment she’d heard of Pam’s unexpected death. Tears appeared in her eyes and she began to shake a little.

That was all I needed.

It was the same with the dog. Emily said even thinking about hearing the news made her feel “just as upset as I did at the time”.

It sounds obvious, but the quickest way to find out whether you need to treat trauma is simply to ask “Does it hurt now when you think about it?”

Which leads into the third way of assessing trauma.

Question 3: Has time stood still?

Traumatic memories, because of how they become trapped between the amygdala (the fight or flight part of the brain) and the hippocampus (an area where recent memories are stored) don’t fade with time like normal memories.

Neutral or pleasant memories start to feel a long time ago as they become stored in the neocortex. But persistent traumatic memories don’t get transferred into long term memory unless we help the client do that.

I have worked with many traumatized people, some of whom had traumas stretching back to the 1940s. But these types of memories, no matter how long ago the trauma was, all felt recent, or even current.

Emily told me that when she thought about those two times she came home from school to terrible news, it didn’t feel like two years had passed at all. It felt like it “happened yesterday”. In fact, Emily told us: “I can still see Dad standing by the kitchen door, telling me Pam is dead, I can see his face, it feels like it’s happening right now.

I asked Emily if she’d like to “put those memories where they belong, in the past” and she said she would. I also suggested to Emily and her mother Jane that I couldn’t be sure, but I thought the fainting may very well stop once those memories had been de-traumatized.

Emily’s new hope

I helped Emily by using the Rewind Technique to decondition the painful emotion from those memories so they no longer had power over her.

She could always feel a little sad whenever she chose to think about Pam or her dog. After the Rewind, we tested how Emily felt about those memories now and she told me something I often hear after a Rewind session: “It feels all faded and really distant now… like it was a very long time ago…”

So the takeaway for uncovering trauma is:

  • Don’t assume there must be a traumatic root to a troublesome symptom but be aware there might be. Ask if anything upsetting occurred before or around the time the symptom first started.
  • Ask if it still hurts even now (not if it hurt at the time) and if they say yes, ask them to think about that time.
  • Ask if the memory feels more recent than it should do, considering how long ago the event occurred.

Emily’s sad memories were put in the past where they belonged. And she never fainted at school again.

Trauma Treatment

Discover How Thousands of Therapists Stop PTSD Symptoms in a Single Session

Click here to find out more

Mark Tyrrell

About Mark Tyrrell

Psychology is my passion. I've been a psychotherapist trainer since 1998, specializing in brief, solution focused approaches. I now teach practitioners all over the world via our online courses.

Find out more about my trauma treatment course here

You can also get my articles on YouTube, find me on Instagram, Amazon, Twitter, and Facebook.

Search for more therapy techniques:

Share via
Send this to a friend